To Their Credit

Games

Nicalis removes generated music from “Binding of Isaac” update after Steam backlash

Tracks in a GTA-themed run carried metadata referring to Suno, while the console patch awaited platform approval.

Ledger: ResistedAI is held back

Nicalis removed generated music from “The Binding of Isaac: Repentance+” after players identified Suno references in tracks used by a Grand Theft Auto-themed in-game run, prompting a sharp backlash on Steam. The replacement patch was live on PC, while versions for Microsoft, Nintendo and Sony platforms had been submitted for approval.

The music had not been disclosed on the game’s Steam description, despite Valve requiring developers to disclose their use of AI in game development. IGN reported that only 8% of recent Steam reviews were positive after the controversy, with reviewers objecting specifically to the previously undisclosed AI material. The game’s recent review status was listed as Overwhelmingly Negative.

The disputed tracks were confined to a GTA-themed run created to coincide with the release of “Grand Theft Auto 6”. Players could activate it with the seed V1CE BSMT, which launched a Vice City-inspired setup with special weapons and music. Kotaku reported that the run contained 14 music files: seven full songs, plus seven intros and outros.

A Reddit user, ShweetsStuff, flagged the music one day after the Nov. 19 update. The user pointed to metadata that named Suno and linked to Suno track pages; one entry read, “made with suno” and showed an Oct. 30 creation date.

Edmund McMillen responded on Nov. 21 that he had not known generated music was in the launch build. “Woke up to a s**t show, obviously I had no idea it featured generated music in the daily run,” he wrote, adding that he was looking into how it happened and getting it removed. Nicalis issued the removal patch hours later, but did not explain how or why the music had been included.

The Nov. 19 release was the console launch of Repentance+, which had arrived as a free PC update in 2024. It brought the package to Nintendo Switch 2, PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X/S. Players had also raised separate complaints about crashes, broken mods, latency and other quality-control problems. The emergency update also included fixes for mods broken by the launch update.

The console upgrade cost $9.99 for existing Repentance owners, while PC players received Repentance+ free. The package added four-player online co-op and built-in item descriptions; crossplay and Steam save imports were promised for a later update.

More from Games

All Games news
  1. Atari veteran warns AI game glut could bury good releasesLedger: Disputed
  2. Unity and OpenAI’s 24-hour game jam crowns three winnersLedger: Adopted
  3. Mikami and Kim split over AI’s role in game developmentLedger: Disputed