Baltimore Sun’s AI cartoons put attribution and authorship under scrutiny
The paper credited its editorial staff collectively after ending Kevin Kallaugher’s 31-year run as its cartoonist.
Ledger: AdoptedAI is taken up

The Baltimore Sun’s use of AI-generated illustrations on its opinion pages has intensified criticism of a newspaper replacing a longtime human political cartoonist while giving the resulting images only a collective editorial-staff credit.
The images began appearing on Aug. 25, 2026, and were published again on Aug. 31, Sept. 1, Sept. 4 and Sept. 5. Captions identified the producer as the Baltimore Sun editorial staff, rather than naming the people who made them. The paper continued to run syndicated hand-drawn cartoons alongside the generated work.
The shift followed the 2025 dismissal of Kevin “KAL” Kallaugher after 31 years at the paper. The Sun described that decision as a cost-cutting measure, saying it would devote its freelance budget to other areas while continuing to use syndicated editorial cartoonists for national and international subjects.
Kallaugher, a two-time Pulitzer finalist and 2015 Herblock Prize winner, said the recurring images amounted to more than a one-off experiment. “This is a pattern,” he said. “This is, I think, the first case in American journalism where AI cartoons have basically become part of a publication’s repertoire.” He distinguished between using AI as visual reference and asking an image generator to produce finished art, arguing that generated political-cartoon styles drew from many sources without an individual voice.
One Aug. 25 image showed the Maryland State Legislature distributing bags marked “Billions!” to people labelled “Non Profits,” accompanied by references to taxpayer dollars and Maryland officials. FAIR criticized the work for relying on labels, generic figures and repeated expressions instead of visual wit, satire or wordplay.
The Association of American Editorial Cartoonists condemned the Sept. 4 illustration, saying it was not drawn by a person and had been generated from “juvenile and uninformed prompts.” The group opposed replacing a human cartoonist with generated imagery and urged editors to reject AI in cartoons and other creative work. It also described Kallaugher’s departure as a cost-cutting move.
The dispute has also raised a narrower question of attribution. The Sun’s captions disclose AI use, but identify only an editorial collective, while the artwork displaces a role historically associated with a named artist. Kallaugher said he had published 11,000 cartoons and remained among a small number of U.S. cartoonists working with pen on paper. CBS Baltimore reported in 2025 that only a handful of political cartoonists still held newspaper jobs.
Concerns over identity extend beyond Baltimore. Nieman Lab documented more than 15 New Yorker cartoonists whose signatures appeared on ChatGPT-generated cartoons without permission or compensation, including a cartoon bearing Brendan Loper’s pen name despite his not drawing or signing it. A New Yorker spokesperson said Condé Nast had not authorized an LLM developer to train on its cartoons.
James Grimmelmann said a signature serves as an indicator of authenticity, but that a copyright claim would probably turn on whether a generator reproduced a particular cartoon rather than a general artistic style. Cartooning for Peace has called for clearer identification and tracing of cartoons, transparency about training material, opt-in use of copyrighted works in training databases and remedies for economic or moral harm.
- Media Journalism, Art and design