To Their Credit

Books Story from

Tamil Nadu arrests publisher in alleged AI library-book procurement fraud

DVAC alleges that books bought for public libraries used fictitious authors, copied material and content created with online tools including ChatGPT.

Ledger: DisputedNo outcome yet

Tamil Nadu’s Directorate of Vigilance and Anti-Corruption arrested Chennai publisher R. Mohan on Nov. 16 in an investigation into alleged fraudulent purchases of books for public libraries. Mohan, proprietor of Agal Vilakku Publications and Phoenix Publications, was accused of supplying books created under fictitious author names, with allegedly plagiarised or AI-generated content, in procurements worth about Rs 1.74 crore.

The arrest came a day after DVAC registered a criminal case against Mohan and unidentified officials from the Directorate of Public Libraries, Anna Centenary Library and Periyar Arivulagam. The case invoked provisions of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, the Prevention of Corruption Act and the Copyright Act concerning conspiracy, cheating, breach of trust, document fabrication and misconduct by public servants.

DVAC searched seven locations, including Mohan’s home, publishing offices and libraries, seizing a hard disk, receipt vouchers and other records. The agency’s inquiry followed a complaint from the School Education Department secretary and found prima facie evidence of forgery, conspiracy and corruption.

The arrest followed the court-ordered inquiry into suspect purchases for Periyar Arivulagam that we covered earlier this month. The investigation focused on allegations raised by writer Perumal Murugan about books carrying fictional author identities, questionable historical claims, factual errors and possible use of AI tools.

According to The Hindu, the Books Recommendation Committee had proposed about 26,000 titles, but the Coordination Committee added further books without recording the additions in the official note file. Investigators said this breached the Tamil Nadu Transparent Book Procurement Policy 2024, under which book lists must pass through selection and price-fixation committees before reaching a high-level committee.

Mohan submitted lists containing 2,339 titles under Agal Vilakku and 99 under Phoenix. Purchase orders covering 1,857 books were issued to the two publishers on Feb. 13 and 14, and 1,779 titles on the Akal Vizhakku list were forwarded for payment after receipt and verification.

The Rs 1.74 crore paid to the two firms covered books supplied to Periyar Arivulagam and other public libraries. The wider state plan had a Rs 50 crore sanction for books and e-books for Periyar Arivulagam, while procurement was intended to extend to libraries in Coimbatore, Tiruchi, Salem, Cuddalore, Tirunelveli and six newly created districts.

DVAC alleged that Mohan created books under false author names using material from websites and online applications, including ChatGPT. It cited books containing factual inaccuracies, such as descriptions of Naladiyar as a poet and philosopher and of the author of “Madurai Kanchi” as a king; it also alleged that “Tourism: Principles, Practices and Philosophies,” attributed to Emily Lawson, copied material from other books.

The inquiry also found that 74 authors were listed by both publishers and that about 10 titles appeared under both imprints with the same author name. The ISBN portal recorded 2,393 books registered by Akal Vizhakku between December 2024 and February, while Phoenix had registered 2,923 titles.

The investigation has already prompted administrative action. Five senior Directorate of Public Libraries officials were suspended on Nov. 15, an audit of public libraries across Tamil Nadu was ordered, and Periyar Arivulagam removed about 2,000 books, including titles from Akal Vilakku.

Three publishers separately proposed a 23-month procurement process and a dedicated procedure for new public libraries, arguing that hurried purchases of large numbers of titles could undermine checks on quality and authenticity. Their proposal included declarations on the use of AI in writing, translation or editing, and random page checks for fabricated or AI-generated material.

School Education and Information & Publicity Minister A. Rajmohan said the roughly Rs 1.75 crore in books identified so far concerned Tamil titles only, and that English-language purchases had yet to be examined.

See also

More from Books

All Books news
  1. SCBWI webinar maps AI pressure across children’s publishingLedger: Resisted
  2. Seoul AI Content Festival pairs generated media with dealmakingLedger: Adopted
  3. Brad Messner’s “My Best Friend Arty” turns an AI companion into humanity’s conquerorLedger: Adopted