To Their Credit

Voice and audio

SAG-AFTRA chief says rules, not an AI ban, are the union’s path

Duncan Crabtree-Ireland said a voice or likeness that clearly evokes a performer should be treated as a digital replica.

Ledger: AdoptedAI is taken up

SAG-AFTRA’s national executive director, Duncan Crabtree-Ireland, said only about 10% to 15% of the union’s 160,000 members want artificial intelligence blocked entirely, while the union is seeking rules that allow performers to work alongside the technology. Speaking at Web Summit in Lisbon on Nov. 12, he said some members want AI tools for augmentation, but none want to be replaced by them.

The union’s approach rests on consent, control and compensation, Crabtree-Ireland said. A synthetic output should count as a digital replica when it is perceived as a person’s voice, clearly sounds like them or looks like them, he said.

Crabtree-Ireland cited OpenAI’s removal of a chatbot voice that drew comparisons with Scarlett Johansson, while noting that OpenAI did not admit using her voice.

SAG-AFTRA’s negotiations with studios and record labels produced what its Senate testimony described as the first comprehensive AI provisions in filmed entertainment and the music industry. Under the union’s television-animation agreements, studios must obtain an actor’s consent to use a digital copy of their voice for foreign-language dubbing and notify the union before licensing performances to outside companies for AI training.

Those animation contracts, ratified with a 94.95% favorable vote, run from July through June 2030 and provide a 12.6% pay rise over four years. Crabtree-Ireland has warned that present-day voice-simulation software can create a convincing replica from a four-second sample, and described a deepfake of himself that falsely urged SAG-AFTRA members to reject a contract.

As reported in October, SAG-AFTRA was among four entertainment unions seeking to challenge a blanket fair-use finding for AI training in OpenAI’s consolidated copyright litigation, arguing that voice actors were already losing work to synthetic voices.

The policy debate remains unresolved at federal level. The U.S. Copyright Office recommended a new law covering highly realistic replicas of all individuals, regardless of celebrity or commercial status, with liability focused on distributing or making unauthorized replicas available rather than creating them alone. The NO FAKES Act, which remains before Congress, is a proposed federal measure intended to protect voices and visual likenesses from unauthorized digital replicas.

The session also addressed technical ways to identify misuse. Dan Neely, Vermillio’s co-founder and chief executive, said its technology is designed to detect unauthorized use and impose guardrails on generated content, including cases in which an output blends multiple voices with original material. Separately, The Voice Realm’s Voice Lock embeds an inaudible signature in actors’ demo recordings; the marketplace says the mark survives editing and can support a dated certificate identifying the associated actor.

See also

More from Voice and audio

All Voice and audio news
  1. Tone launches AI voice platform built to steer delivery toward a goalLedger: Adopted
  2. Equity ballot puts UK film and TV AI consent rules to the testLedger: Adopted
  3. Murder Drones actor says Voicemod used her voice without consentLedger: Disputed